Then there is the contempt that Hamlet heaps on Osric, Rosencrantz & Guildenstern, and Polonius, which is not unlike the contempt Caulfield displays toward all the phonies like his girlfriend, "old Sally. Holden Caulfield even mentions Hamlet. Holden starts getting sick of Mr. Antaloni's witty … He disagrees with Holden. Hamlet is in a similar situation he is slowly losing his mind and talking to ghosts when he should be dealing with problems right in front of him. Hamlet’s madness, which if acted, would have been put under two different categories in the era it was written. As one gets deeper into the book, the psychosis picks up and takes on a vertiginous, frenetic quality as if Caulfield risks falling into a vortex. His picture quote further supports this, as one of the characters in the play is poisoned through their ear. Mr. Antaloni says, "there is a time and a place for everything."
In the quote “boy, I felt miserable. Holden’s state of madness, is however, not influenced by the supernatural, but more by the society around him. When he picks up a magazine in Grand Central Station, he reads an article in which he seems to resemble the man in the piece who has "lousy hormones"; then, he reads an article about sores in your mouth possibly leading to cancer. After making a date with Sally he started obsessing about money saying “it always ends up making you blue as hell”. When he doesn't immediately throw her down and go at it, she gets irritated. Of course Holden says this about many things, including crossing the street, going to different schools, having a roommate and so on. Answer. Hamlet is thinking about the meaning of life and death and what it means to really live in the world that is before him, or to pretend to live in another world in his dreams. Surely we have reached the end, they will say, when one can consider When he says "there's the rub," he means "there's the drawback." The parallel is in fact made by Caulfield himself when he discusses seeing the Laurence Olivier version of Furthermore, Caulfield's world-weariness echoes that of Hamlet, the most world-weary of young men (though he is 30 years old, not a teen like Caulfield). Hamlet and Holden Clinton W. Trowbridge Department of English Adelphi Suffolk College Oakdale, New York TO some, I fear, what I am about to argue will seem the most blatant form of mistruth, horrendous, even, in its lack of taste, a kind of literary sacrilege, in fact. Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent straight to you.Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost's next chapterWe made it easy for you to exercise your right to vote!Part of HuffPost Entertainment. What I did, I started talking, sort of out loud, to Allie” (98). Add your voice! You have to give up your power to others because it is really the way you can truly live your life. All rights reserved.Important conversations are happening now. Holden Caulfield is dealing with his own mortality and decisions including whether or not grow up and deal with or to hide away in his fantasies. Holden says it is more authentic when a person gets caught up in something, and it also lets him know more about their character. Holden Caulfield feels powerless in his life. Holden Caulfield even mentions Hamlet. Holden heads over to the Mall (as in an outside area without cars, not as in an indoor shopping mall) hoping to run into Phoebe in the park. Hamlet can be depressed in one moment then in another be in a full rage. He enjoyed the smallest part of the play were Ophelia was “horsening around with her brother and teasing him” but the larger meaning of the play was lost to him because he kept “worrying about whether he's going to do something phony every minute”. In William Shakespeare's Hamlet the “ to be or not to be” speech is all about Hamlet dealing with his problems. Perhaps death will bring hellish nightmares. His English and Japanese names start the same way as "hamster", his species. Holden, of course, is aware of the mutability of time. And while Caulfield gets into two fights in the book, he does not start them. ... Who does Holden say is the worst slob in The Catcher in the Rye? Holden and Romeo are very similar in the sense that they both make decisions using their emotions.
All rights reserved. 1 2. In honor of April Fools' Day, I thought it appropriate to pay homage to that jokester, much beloved of all adolescents and many adults, Holden Caulfield, protagonist of But I am less interested in his pranksterism than I am in his mental state. In Hamlet's famous speech he believes that are giving up some of your power when you are at the mercy of “outrageous fortunes”. Choose one to four lines from the "To Be or Not to Be" soliloquy from
The disagreement turns angry, and Holden tells Sally that she gives him "a royal pain in the ass." Hamlet also speaks to the dead in the form of ghosts.